How does stardust the movie compare to stardust the book. Aug 09, 2019 stardust is still one of the best neil gaiman adaptations out there. It seems like in this day and age, if we arent interested from the get go, we dont even have the motivation to wait until the end. It was quite a while after watching and loving the film stardust that i discovered it was an adaptation, based on a book by neil gaiman. All in all, when a book based movie comes out in theaters, we want it to be as epic, awesome, and excellent as the book it was based on. Sometimes the book is betterones imagination can surely be more entertaining than what hollywood tosses out, right. But when it comes down to it, is the book really better than the movie. Dec 18, 2008 this isnt really an answer to the question anymore just a book vs movie poll, but ive always felt very strongly about stardust. But the movie takes the concept of the book and makes it sing. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics.
Although the underlying storyline is the same in both the book and the film, there are numerous differences. Jun 04, 2011 sometimes the book is betterones imagination can surely be more entertaining than what hollywood tosses out, right. Watching the stardust film was obviously a lot easier than watching the king lear interpretation. A fantasy, even a comic fantasy, needs above all to be lean and uncluttered. Mar 08, 2015 stardust, the movie, was produced in 2007.
Im on the side that enjoyed the book more than the movie, and i was always hugely surprised to find how many people preferred the movie to the book. Tristran thorn promises to bring back a fallen star for his beloved, the hauntingly beautiful victoria. Based on a comic book series by acclaimed graphic novelist neil gaiman, stardust is a mashup of the princess bride, the neverending story and pretty in pinkwith nods to c. Ranking the terrible jojo localization names duration.
Ive already seen the film stardust several times not only because i adore claire danes but so far never had the time to check out the novel by neil gaiman. Anyone who has read both the book and seen the movie will know that the stardust. Wybie kid, wybies grandmother, the dolls, the garden, the praying mantus lawnmower, the piano with the. Featured comparison the sum of all fears 88 differences. In both the movie and the book, feelings of suspense rise within us, especially when reading or watching the odyssey. Best of all, it can be used over and over again with any book that has a movie companion. Stardust 1,2,3,4 of 4 being a romance within the realms of faerie, volumes 1,2,3,4 thats all. I still like the movie better, but gaimans writing is so extraordinary. In stephen kings it, the narrative is split between two time periods. Oct 30, 2017 stardust is another great example of that. First, students will identify and record similarities and differences between the book and movie usin. I saw the movie before reading the book, and i definitely preferred the movie. Movie coraline is sort of a brat, but it makes her development much more rewarding at the end of the film.
Stardust is a 2007 romantic fantasy adventure film directed by matthew vaughn and cowritten by vaughn and jane goldman. Dunstan thorn lives in the tiny town of wall, and when hes eighteen, he crosses through the wall to attend the onceeverynineyears faerie market. Among his numerous literary awards are the newbery and carnegie medals, and the hugo, nebula, world fantasy, and will eisner awards. For obvious reasons, this film was almost forced to be a modern adaptation due to the time period it was released in. Stardust is still one of the best neil gaiman adaptations out there.
Checkout nasas perspective on the great hit movie, the martian, staring matt damon. And while that is, as beginnings go, not entirely novel for every tale about every young man there ever was or will be could start in a similar manner there was much about this young man and. Coraline does not consider other mothers world pleasant at all. An example of when the director uses a lowangle shot to make the character look less powerful is when tristan is standing outside victorias house throwing a rocks at her window waiting for her to come out while humphrey comes and throws him on the ground and points his sword at him, when tristan is on the ground and humphrey is putting on foot on top of him the director. How does stardust the movie compare to stardust the.
Anyone who has read both the book and seen the movie will know that. The crucible comparing play and movie arthur millers play, the crucible, and the movie with the same name have many differences and similarities, all of which contribute to the individual effectiveness of each in conveying their central message. This resource compares the book and the movie, integrating language, media, and visual arts. Yvaine has a bigger role in the book than she does in the movie. Stardust is still one of the best neil gaiman adaptations. There are several additions and variances in the movie. Listen up, kids, stardust might be written in the style of a fairytale, but that doesnt mean its going to take you by the hand and guide you through the woods, er, plot. British author neil gaimans 1999 novel stardust is a fantasy often considered to. Wybie kid, wybies grandmother, the dolls, the garden, the praying mantus lawnmower, the piano with the hands coming out of it, the gloves coraline gets at. Stardust serafin book, a posthumous collection of memoirs and essays by bruce serafin stardust parker novel, by robert parker star dust book, a. Free use these two printables after you have read the book and then seen the movie version. If i had to point out any kind of change, it would be that she is a bit more selfish and whiney in the movie, which isnt necessarily a bad thing. I will read the book and watch the movie again and again.
Or, you could always get the original graphic novel in 4 parts. What are some differences between the movie and book. There are also occasions where the big wigs in hollywood outdo the imagination and give us a masterpiece. Rotten tomatoes watching the stardust film was obviously a lot easier than watching the king lear interpretation. Thats unusual, and its particularly unusual when the book is written by an author as good as neil gaiman. The classic fantasy structure involves the hero, the quest, the prize and what stands in the way. All in all, when a bookbased movie comes out in theaters, we want it to be as epic, awesome, and excellent as the book it was based on. In shelleys novel frankensteins monster had got his head cut because of frankensteins need to put the brain in his creation, not by an axe. While rush hour 3 raked in the bucks in the tens of millions, and bourne and the simpsons added to their already impressive piles, poor stardust only took in nine million bucks. The film that best exemplifies that criteria is stardust official site, which is the winner of the weekly website award. Get the run down on what could be legitimately possible and whats not. In the book coraline is a bit more formal and polite, but that might be because the book takes place in england, and the movie has her talking like any other girl from michigan would.
It includes questions, charts, a scaffolded compare and contrast essay template, and more. I did enjoy this, but i think it should be kept in mind that this really is a childrens story. How is the original frankenstein movie 1931 different from. She moves into a new house with her parents and shes generally sweet to all of her strange neighbors. The novel was based on four comic books, written by neil gaiman and illustrated by charles vess, first published in 199798. Stardust is still one of the best neil gaiman adaptations out. Even today, two townsmen stand on either side of the opening, night and day, taking eighthour shifts. First, i must say stardust is one of my favorite movies ever, so i wasnt sure about reading the book.
Coraline is a childrens book, so it gets right to the plot. The book and movie ending are vastly different but both are very enjoyable. There were some different aspects to the book than the movie, and i really liked seeing the differences. Great for comparing and contrasting and thinking critically about how the movie was made. Quite how this fact passed me by i couldnt say but when. Even with my appreciation for the movie the effects, the way it was shot, and, of course, the actors who were amazing, by the way it still didnt cut it for me. Catherine, mikayla, kai, maryn and braith welcome to wall about a nights drive from london, this tiny victorian village was very creatively named after the giant wall that stands next to it. Chapter one in which we learn of the village of wall, and of the curious thing that occurs there every nine years there was once a young man who wished to gain his hearts desire. Being a romance within the realms of faerie if you get that one you will not be disappointed. I read the book for stardust after watching the movie, and i was rather shocked at how the book ends compared to the movie. It was collected as a novel in 1998 and was gaimans second solo novel. Hes told hell get his hearts desire, which in this case means shacking up with an exoticlooking slave woman. For me, the graphic novel was a totally unique experience it showed me an entire new art, a new way of telling stories, which was mindopening for a mind just then entering adulthood. This onepage guide includes a plot summary and brief analysis of stardust by neil gaiman.
I think for once i actually prefer the movie ending over the book ending. Ive read the graphic novel version of stardust and loved it. I ordered stardust by mistake at first, then figured out that the right one was stardust. The movie was pretty good, but it pales in comparison to the actual book. Also, without the casting of daisy, tristans sister louisa is not in the movie, thus giving tristan no female guidance in his upbringing. Another big list of movie sites, but not much in the way of topnotch entries.
Tristan and yvain dont both rise to the sky, living forever together among the stars. It is not a good sign that almost the most entertaining element of stardust is captain shakespeare appearing from the skies in his dirigible pirate ship. According to wikipedia, the film is more different than it is similar. The exclusion of daisy twists the entire plot of the movie in comparison to the book, because dunstans quest is double sided. While its pretty easy to follow a story about going on a quest to find your hearts desire, thats a way oversimplified take on this story, and the reality is that theres moral ambiguity in spades, plus. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. A faithful interpretation that captures the spirit of whimsy, action, and offkilter humor of neil gaiman, stardust juggles multiple genres and tones to create a. Use the book and movie to teach students how to effectively compare and contrast. A faithful interpretation that captures the spirit of whimsy, action, and offkilter humor of neil gaiman, stardust juggles multiple genres and tones to create a fantastical experience. Recently i was roaming the book shelves of my favourite library and stumbled upon. Yes, this movie is based on the novel of the same name, stardust. Actually, the movie ending is a little happier than the book.
Jun 04, 2008 the ending is really rather different between the book and the movie for stardust. In the book, the abomination taught himself to read, write and talk. For a movie site to be an award winner, i expect it to have all of the usual features, extras like clips, something interactive like a game, and background sound and animation. But i have to say, this one gave me a run for my money. It boasts a plotline tailored to teens and tweens, and a starfilled cast michelle pfeiffer, robert. How is the original frankenstein movie 1931 different. Although the underlying storyline is the same in both the book and the film, there are numerous differences in the details of the plot. This comprehensive standardsbased lesson includes everything you need for a successful book vs. This is backwards because i saw the movie first and it became and instant favorite to me before i ever considered reading the book. Compare and contrast a book and movie activities teaching. The biggest difference you notice is they completely left out tristans trek to find the star.
For a no prep way to have students compare and contrast a book with its movie, check out my book vs. The ending is really rather different between the book and the movie for stardust. For a no prep way to have students compare and contras t a book with its movie, check out my book vs. But this isnt about the comparison between the two films. This comprehensive lesson plan includes 30 daily lessons, 180 multiple choice questions, 20 essay questions, 20 fun activities, and more everything you need to teach stardust. If youve watched the film then id suggest reading the book and viceversa. Jul 07, 2014 i read this at the start of june 2014. What are some differences between the movie and book coraline. Nine months later, when hes already married a girl in wall, a. The local library despite not allowing us to check out dvds for free and not having tennis magazine has a nice little collection of graphic novels.
850 1412 1217 1674 185 1068 131 1157 435 1497 1306 1450 540 902 581 183 1184 1328 377 1470 1374 1218 1114 566 929 223 1367 66 679 842 1248 914 1108 918 926